Posted by Robin Marshall on February 25, 2010 at 18:00:43 user TARSUS.
In Reply to: Re: PM review on Amazon posted by John Lambert on February 25, 2010 at 14:55:03:
Bobby the Arc Welder presumably did not read Secret Water, Nancy is far from a wife and mother in that, which was the book that was a follow on to PM, The one good thing he urge's readers to buy the book.
I doubt he is a professional reviewer and the other ones reviewing the book are all more in line with our view of the story.
Nancy certainly displayed her sensible side, not that the Doctor, Postnman, and Timothy would agree.
I always liked the story especially skinning the rabbit,certainly something most would feel squeamish about.